AI and Copyright: A Shifting Landscape

The issue of copyright infringement in the face of Artificial Intelligence poses unique challenges that require careful consideration and potential adjustments to existing laws. In general, copyright law grants exclusive rights to creators of original works, including artists, to control the reproduction, distribution, and public display or performance of their creations. These rights are intended to incentivize creativity and allow creators to benefit from their intellectual efforts.

But when it comes to AI-generated content, such as art or music created by machine learning algorithms, the question of who holds the copyright becomes much more complex. In most jurisdictions, copyright protection is granted to human creators, and AI systems are not recognized as legal persons eligible for copyright protection. As a result, AI-generated content typically doesn't qualify for copyright protection itself.

However, if a human creator is involved in the AI's creative process, such as training the algorithm or making significant creative decisions, they may be considered the author of the resulting work and may be entitled to copyright protection. This scenario is often referred to as "human-assisted AI" or "human-AI collaboration."

To address the challenges posed by AI-generated content, some jurisdictions have considered implementing changes to copyright law. For instance, there have been discussions around introducing a new category of "AI authorship" or granting certain rights to the AI itself.  The proposals aim to maintain consistency with the goals of copyright law, even when applied to the protection and attribution of AI-generated works.

Additionally, some countries have implemented or are considering implementing specific provisions, such as fair use or fair dealing exceptions, to accommodate transformative uses of copyrighted works by AI systems. These exceptions aim to strike a balance between protecting the rights of creators, whilst still fostering innovation and societal benefits arising from AI technologies. It's worth noting that copyright law is just one aspect of the broader legal and regulatory landscape concerning AI. AI regulations are being developed to address various concerns, including safety, accountability, transparency, and ethical considerations associated with AI systems. These regulations focus on mitigating risks, ensuring transparency in AI decision-making, and safeguarding fundamental rights.

As AI technologies continue to evolve, lawmakers and policymakers are actively monitoring and adapting legal frameworks to address the unique challenges posed by AI-generated content, while preserving the rights of creators and considering the overall societal impact.

This topic was discussed in depth during a recent Arcual Reflections talk at Art Basel with Art Consultant and Lawyer, Simon Oldfield, which looked at the issue within the frame of the Andy Warhol "Orange Price" Supreme Court Case. Watch the full talk here!

‍

Stay tuned for more from Arcual Blog!

‍